To Be Done or Not Done (When I Know A Story Is Finished) by Atreyee Gupta

Today it is with great pleasure to welcome my guest, Atreyee Gupta. We’ve been blogging buddies over the years. Here’s the link to her blog, Bespoke Traveler. Last year Atreyee contacted me to review her book,  Cities of Kings. I was thrilled to receive the request since I love helping my fellow bloggers promote their books and this book is about London and Paris. I now live in London and each spring we hop over to Paris for a long weekend. Her book was a perfect fit for me.

Here’s the synopsis on Goodreads:

18070362(2)“Cities of Kings” relates the stories of how kings and queens helped build the various architecture of two giant European cities: London and Paris. The book takes a look at why these two cities look so different even though they have shared a common royal past, often being ruled by the same monarchs. Through stories about the construction and design of important sights such as Buckingham Palace, Tower of London, Louvre Palace, and Notre Dame de Paris, the book reveals the political desires and aesthetic passions of the royals who dreamt up these landmarks. The book also studies how the modern architecture of London and Paris finds a place amongst the cities’ historical palaces and castles. By telling stories about the most famous historic buildings of two important European cities, this book shows how the two cities can be discovered afresh by travelers from an architectural perspective.

I recommend this book to anyone who loves history, architecture and the cities. It’s well researched, entertaining, insightful, and a wonderful addition for history and travel lovers.

And now for the good stuff. After I read and reviewed her book I asked Atreyee to write a guest post for my blog. She was kind enough to accept. Without further ado, here’s Atreyee:

To be done or not done, that is the question every writer confronts. It’s a question I

struggle with every time I put pen to paper or stare at the letters on my keyboard. Have I

gotten all my points across to the audience? Are my characters truly at the end of their

development? Is there one last surprise left in the story? For me, writing is similar to

traveling. When I decide where to go, it’s based on what I want to discover and achieve.

Uncovering the story behind why and how royalty was inspired to build English

architectural masterpieces takes me to certain places. Places very different from when I

wanted to understand how Persian philosophy and Hindu craft had mingled to create

nineteenth century Indian artwork. In the same way, my stories and books begin with an

objective of what I want to explore, whether that is a historical turning point, a classic

moral dilemma, or solving a whodunit. In my travels, when I have seen what I came to

see and experienced a relationship with my destination, I can happily return home.

When I have solved my mystery, resolved the major quandary, and feel satisfied with my

writing, then I am content to send off my story.


The final sentence in my tale always signals the destination I wish to reach, but long

before I visualize that phrase at the bottom of the last page, I do what any good traveler

does: plan. I plan for the things I want to see happen in the story, for how the characters

develop, and for the inevitable sudden turns my narrative might take. Detours, in writing

plot lines and characters, just as in travel routes, are a way of life. A character may run

into a dead end, the plot may produce snafus, and the adventure might become

entangled, but that doesn’t mean that my story can’t be finished. When things deviate, I

ponder whether the essence of my story remains feasible. Any story worth telling, just

like any destination worth visiting, doesn’t offer up easy formulas. I simply work harder

to discover those resolutions.


Knowing when my tale is concluded is different from termination of the story.

Philosophically speaking, a story is never finished. In my travels, there is always more

sights I could have seen, more history I could have researched, and more people I

could have interacted with. For me, part of the enchantment of traveling is that despite

my having uncovered and understood a place, it has more to be discovered, more ways

to be looked at. I like to think the same magic lies in good writing. The author shows

readers only a partial unveiling. Beyond the last page, the characters continue to live

their lives into the future, the worlds created on the page progress through literary time.

The important stories never end, they simply proceed behind closed doors.

Understanding this distinction, for me, has been a combination of experience in writing

and reading others’ stories. Instead of being unsatisfied that I haven’t learned everything

about a city or town, I enjoy mastering one facet of its personality. In my writing, I focus

on whether I have brought to light a single kernel and presented it correctly. That is

when my story is truly done.

About TBM

TB Markinson is an American who's recently returned to the US after a seven-year stint in the UK and Ireland. When she isn't writing, she's traveling the world, watching sports on the telly, visiting pubs in New England, or reading. Not necessarily in that order. Her novels have hit Amazon bestseller lists for lesbian fiction and lesbian romance. She cohosts the Lesbians Who Write Podcast ( with Clare Lydon. TB also runs I Heart Lesfic (, a place for authors and fans of lesfic to come together to celebrate lesbian fiction.
This entry was posted in Guest Posts and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

23 Responses to To Be Done or Not Done (When I Know A Story Is Finished) by Atreyee Gupta

  1. Sherri says:

    Sounds like a very interesting read about two of my favourite cities, London and Paris! TB, how lovely that you get to travel to Paris in the spring. We hope to go back again one of these days, last time it was November and bitterly cold. I also enjoyed Atreyee’s guest post. I like how she says, ‘The important stories never end, they simply proceed behind closed doors.’ Fascinating, thank you.

    • TBM says:

      It’s been cold the last two times, but we go during the French Open so we don’t get to choose a warmer time. Lately, though, the weather has been pleasant so maybe this is our year.

      • Sherri says:

        Ahh…the French Open, wonderful! Give Rafa a big hug and kiss from me will you? (I’m a huge fan!!). Hope the weather stays good for you too 🙂

      • TBM says:

        When I first saw Rafa play (on the telly) I wasn’t a huge fan. I thought he was too big and didn’t have the finesse for tennis. then I watched him live and he won me over completely. Now I even have a Vamos Rafa tee I wear every time I see him play. Last year we saw his first round match at the French and it was a special moment. He owns that tournament.

    • Sherri, I always have the feeling that after I have turned the last page of a book I finish reading and closed its covers, somewhere the characters go on living their intriguing lives blissfully unaware that I was looking in! 😀

  2. cheriereich says:

    Lovely post! And I’m with Sherri. I love the line: The important stories never end, they simply proceed behind closed doors.

    That’s so, so true!

  3. cleemckenzie says:

    I love history and architecture when they’re woven into good stories. Good luck, to Atreyee with her book.

  4. Thanks for introducing us to Atreyee and her book…it sounds like a great read. Ah, a long weekend in Paris, in the spring no less…NICE!

  5. restlessjo says:

    I’ve read this one and Atreyee is a wise and inspiring traveller, TBM.
    Hope life’s treating you well 🙂

  6. Reblogged this on Bespoke Traveler and commented:
    My blogging friend TB, an accomplished author, was not only kind enough to review our book “Cities of Kings” but also asked me to write a little something for her as a guest author! Here is what I wrote.

  7. Thank you TB, not only for the kind review of the “Cities of Kings” book, but also for asking me to guest post about my writing! It is always such a wonderful pleasure to read your reviews and discover other authors out there and I am thrilled to be in the mix with them.

    • TBM says:

      It was a pleasure having you here. It’s fun getting to know so many bloggers and cheering them on. Thanks for all of your support and best of luck!

  8. I love the idea that stories proceed behind closed doors after we end them. I like to think that characters live on.

    • TBM says:

      Love the new photo, Medeia! And it is a nice thought to think that even though we aren’t watching, the characters still live.

  9. Kourtney Heintz says:

    I love how you put it how important stories don’t end, the continue behind closed doors. That’s how a great book always feels to me too!

  10. marjma2014 says:

    Lovely post. Very thoughtful. Sounds like an interesting book, thanks for the review.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s